Innerarity Island Real Estate Search

Innerarity Island Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Innerarity Island real estate search for homes, condo, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Innerarity Island Popular Searches
Innerarity Island Properties by Price
Innerarity Island Properties by # of Bedroom(s)
Innerarity Island Properties by # of Bathroom(s)

Curious about what’s happening in the Innerarity Island real estate market? Sign up for a  Innerarity Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Innerarity Island Properties for Sale

$1,325,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 627591 MLS
Southern living water front home with wrap around porch and breathtaking views! Home remodeled within the last five years! HVAC 2023. Bottom floor mini split 2023. Gunite salt water pool with spa 2019. New Roof 2019. New Dock 2020. This custom home, full of natural light from the many windows, has 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths, a beautiful, recently renovated kitchen with gas range, granite countertops, and custom backsplash, Great Room with gas FP, Dining Area, large Florida Room, crown molding, tall ceilings, wood and tile floors, a large Master Suite with walk in closets and a completely renovated Master Bathroom. On the ground floor is a Guest Suite with Living Area/Man Cave, LVP flooring and bead board walls (small kitchen could easily be added) as well as a workshop and lots of storage.

5578 North Shore Way, Pensacola
$78,000
626628 MLS
Enjoy living on a private island here Florida EVERY. SINGLE. DAY. Enjoy the most stunning sunsets that our slice of Florida has to offer from the island's beach or community park each and every evening. This lot is high and dry on a quiet street with oak trees and native Florida vegetation. Confidently build the home of your dreams here one of the highest elevations on the island. While you live here you'll see Osprey, local foxes, deer, bald eagles, and other local wildlife as much of the gated island is still in its natural state. Also, the private beach and community waterfront park are convenient stops for your bike rides and morning walks. Buy and build the house of your dreams to begin enjoying our island lifestyle! The property is just minutes to a local boat ramp, Publix shopping center, Perdido Key beaches and the Gulf.

16358 Shore Dr, Pensacola
$800,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 626239 MLS
You'll love this sublime Innerarity Island Pool Home! This immaculate EarthCents Certified, 2-story, 3 bedroom, 2½ bath home exudes modern elegance. The expansive front porch incorporates a welcoming hand-crafted double exterior door that invites you to step into 2,445 square feet of pristine style. This captivating home features a spacious open floor plan with a first floor master suite, marble countertops throughout, engineered hardwood floors, and a chef’s kitchen with stainless steel Kitchenaid appliances and a 6-burner gas stove, perfect for entertaining and socializing with friends and family. Additional features include PGT impact rated windows, icynene spray foam insulation in the roof, 2x6 construction, and (2) 16-seer air conditioning units wired for a portable generator. The backyard paradise has an in ground gunite pool with a new pump that features a 3-year warranty, gas hookup for family BBQs and provides plenty of shade with mature oak trees and green space views. The 3-car garage sanctuary boasts a roomy 1,200 square foot space perfect for cars, trucks, boats and motorcycles. The hot tub powered by dedicated 240V circuit so it can quickly heat up. Schedule your private showing today!

5781 Red Cedar St, Pensacola
$119,500
624949 MLS
DON’T MISS THIS AMAZING OPPORTUNITY to build your dream home situated at the western edge of Innerarity Island! This is the perfect location for a raised home on pilings to capture panoramic views of the preserve, canals and bay as well as enjoy stunning year-round sunsets. Innerarity Island is a gated community surrounded by nature and wildlife including deer, red fox, heron, and osprey! Just a short walk to the community waterfront park or enjoy the quiet roads for a morning bike ride! Only minutes from the beautiful beaches of Perdido Key…

5420 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$119,500
624948 MLS
DON’T MISS THIS AMAZING OPPORTUNITY to build your dream home on Innerarity Island! Located at the western edge of the island, this is the perfect location for a raised home on pilings to capture panoramic views of the preserve, canals and bay as well as enjoy stunning year-round sunsets. Innerarity Island is a gated community surrounded by nature and wildlife including deer, red fox, heron, and osprey! Just a short walk to the community waterfront park or enjoy the quiet roads for a morning bike ride! Only minutes from the beautiful beaches of Perdido Key…

5418 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$175,000
623426 MLS
Enjoy Pensacola's Stunning Sunsets EVERY. SINGLE. DAY. Want to overlook Perdido Bay and enjoy the most stunning sunsets that our slice of Florida has to offer each and every evening? Then these is the lots are for you. Yes, "lots" meaning you get 2 contiguous lots which together are over a half acre. These lots face south on coveted and gated Innerarity Island located across the street from the water. Here, you will be able to build the house of your dreams with second-floor water views...

5606 Innerarity Cir, Pensacola
$129,000
612531 MLS
Click on the 'MUST SEE' VIRTUAL TOUR..Beautiful and True Island Life !! Two lots side by side. See 5400 North Shore also listed. Your dream home is waiting for you. This lot is partially cleared and has a fantastic view of beautiful sunsets and bird life, nests atop tall pines. It is your choice of where you want to clear for your dream home. The lot is unobstructed from waterview so as you build your home on pilings you will have one of the best views imagined without the high price of waterfront. Located at the end of Innerarity Point Island, Innerarity Pt Rd dead ends at this lot straight ahead. See also lot 9 for sale. Some photos were taken when the lot was cleared several years ago.

5314 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$129,000
612526 MLS
Click on the 'MUST SEE' VIRTUAL TOUR..Beautiful and True Island Life !! Two lots side by side. Fantastic location overlooking the Intercoastal Waterway of Perdido Bay. This quiet waterfront neighborhood lot is at the tip of Innerarity Island, on the last road at the end of Innerarity Island with gorgeous, breathtaking views of the sunset, natural bird life, tall pines and more. Customize your dream home nestled in natural island vegetation and your choice of your surroundings with the opportunity to have this lot cleared exactly the way you want it for your home to be built wherever you want, however you want. Whether it be in the midst of natural trees and shrubs with privacy, or cleared for a more open style lot with your beautiful home on display. Building on pilings to oversee this waterfront, protected by the marshland is the best of both worlds! A MUST SEE homesite !

5400 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$65,500
610679 MLS
Wonderful wooded lot on .37 acres on North Shore Rd near the end of Innerarity Island, ready to build your dream home! Innerarity Island is a gated community surrounded by nature and wildlife including deer, red fox, heron, and osprey! Just a short walk to the community waterfront park or enjoy the quiet roads for a morning bike ride! Only minutes from the beautiful beaches of Perdido Key…

5433 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$210,000
599889 MLS
Opportunity to acquire 2 lots (over .65 acre) on gated Innerarity Island located across the street from Perdido Bay and with greenbelts on south and west side. Road frontage on two streets. Community bay front park just steps away. Wetland study completed and there are no wetlands on the parcels.

5400blk/5451 North Shore Rd, Pensacola
$499,000
592408 MLS
This deep water southern exposure Intercoastal front lot on a cul-de-sac with a white sand beach is located behind the gates of Innerarity Island, and is ready for your waterfront oasis. Just minutes by boat to Alabama Pass, the Gulf of Mexico, and great restaurants and bars (FloraBama, Pirate's Cove, Hub Stacy's...). The opportunity to acquire this caliber of property has become scarce. Per neighborhood covenants- the home building setback from the water can be in-line with existing neighboring homes.

5870 Red Cedar St, Pensacola
$59,900
597588 MLS
Build your Dream Home in the coveted gated community of "Innerarity Island", nestled between Perdido Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway. Love and Live the Coastal Lifestyle everyday with this location close to Perdido Key, the Alabama Coast, the waterways, the beautiful white sandy beaches of the Key, and yet so close to the back gate of NAS and downtown Pensacola as well. Grocery stores, shopping, restaurants, and a public boat launch are just minutes away. The Island boasts it's own community "Recreation Area" with water access for your water activities; or simply just to picnic and soak in the sights and sounds of the wildlife abound in this private and quiet community. Come home to your very own piece of Paradise every night!

5606 North Shore Way, Pensacola
$59,900
597590 MLS
Build your Dream Home in the coveted gated community of "Innerarity Island", nestled between Perdido Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway. Love and Live the Coastal Lifestyle everyday with this location close to Perdido Key, the Alabama Coast, the waterways, the beautiful white sandy beaches of the Key, and yet so close to the back gate of NAS and downtown Pensacola as well. Grocery stores, shopping, restaurants, and a public boat launch are just minutes away. The Island boasts it's own community "Recreation Area" with water access for your water activities; or simply just to picnic and soak in the sights and sounds of the wildlife abound in this private and quiet community. Come home to your very own piece of Paradise every night!

5581 Seascape Dr, Pensacola
Start Your Search

Copyright© 2016 by the Multiple Listing Service of the Pensacola Association of REALTORS® This information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Subject to verification by all parties. This data is copyrighted and may not be transmitted, retransmitted, copied, framed, repurposed, or altered in any way for any other site, individual and/or purpose without the express written permission of the Multiple Listing Service of the Pensacola Association of REALTORS®. Florida recognizes single and transaction agency relationships. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Any use of search facilities of data on this site, other than by a consumer looking to purchase real estate, is prohibited.